Are Compression Fractures Painful?

A compression fracture occurs when a vertebra collapses into itself. This collapse is most frequently caused by underlying conditions like osteoporosis, which weakens the bone structure, making it susceptible to fracture from minor stress or even spontaneously. The structural change generally results in pain. Understanding the nature and duration of this pain, from immediate discomfort to longer-term issues, is helpful for anyone experiencing this injury.

The Characteristics of Acute Pain

The immediate pain following a compression fracture is often sharp and intense, usually localized to the mid-back or lower back, corresponding to the fractured vertebra. This acute discomfort arises from several mechanical factors. First, fractured bone fragments move against each other, irritating nerve endings in the bone.

The change in spinal alignment also triggers painful muscle spasms as surrounding muscles attempt to stabilize the unstable segment of the spine. The pain is positional, meaning it worsens noticeably with movement. Simple actions like standing, walking, twisting, coughing, or sneezing can intensify the discomfort.

Conversely, the pain often lessens when the person lies down, as this position relieves gravitational pressure on the compromised vertebral body. Pain can also be referred, meaning it radiates away from the injury site. This referred pain may be felt in the abdomen, hip, groin, or along the ribs.

The acute pain typically lasts for a few days to a week. For most people, the pain begins to decrease after about four weeks and often resolves completely within two to three months as the bone heals. The severity of the pain does not always correlate with the degree of vertebral collapse, as some fractures, particularly those related to osteoporosis, may occur gradually with minimal initial pain.

Managing Initial Discomfort

Controlling acute pain is important for promoting recovery. Standard conservative care begins with activity modification, involving a brief period of rest to allow pain and swelling to subside. However, prolonged bed rest is discouraged because it can lead to muscle deconditioning and hasten bone density loss.

Instead, the focus is on a gradual, guided return to activity as comfort permits, often supported by physical therapy. Pharmacological management is employed to reduce pain and muscle spasms. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) or acetaminophen are commonly used as first-line options for mild to moderate pain.

For more severe pain, a healthcare provider may prescribe short-term use of stronger pain relievers or muscle relaxants to alleviate intense spasms. Calcitonin is another effective initial treatment for the first few weeks, offering short-term pain relief and facilitating earlier mobilization. These medications are used cautiously, especially in older adults, to minimize the risk of side effects.

External support, such as a back brace, may be prescribed to limit spinal movement and reduce pain by immobilizing the fractured area. While bracing offers comfort and stability, its long-term benefits are debated, and it must be used with a plan for mobility. The goal of initial management is to stabilize the patient and allow natural bone healing.

When Pain Becomes a Chronic Issue

While most acute compression fractures heal within 12 weeks, pain persists in 30 to 40 percent of individuals one year after the fracture. When pain continues beyond the expected healing period, it is considered chronic and is often linked to structural problems arising from the initial injury. This persistent discomfort may be due to continued micro-motion at the fracture site, which prevents the bone from fully stabilizing.

The collapse of the vertebra can also lead to a progressive change in the spine’s curvature, known as kyphosis, which alters the biomechanics of the entire back. This abnormal posture places chronic strain on the spinal ligaments, muscles, and adjacent vertebrae, leading to ongoing pain and functional limitation. Furthermore, the altered structure can narrow the spaces where nerves exit the spine, potentially causing chronic nerve impingement and radiating discomfort.

For patients whose chronic pain significantly impacts their quality of life and does not respond to continued conservative treatments after several months, advanced, minimally invasive interventions may be considered. These procedures, such as vertebroplasty or kyphoplasty, aim to stabilize the fractured bone. Both involve injecting a specialized bone cement directly into the collapsed vertebra under image guidance.

Kyphoplasty further involves the temporary insertion and inflation of a balloon to partially restore the vertebral height before the cement is injected, which can reduce the spinal deformity. By stabilizing the unstable bone structure, these procedures often provide rapid and sustained pain relief, allowing patients to regain mobility and reduce their reliance on pain medication. The decision to pursue these interventions is typically made when the fracture pain remains intractable after three months of comprehensive conservative care.