What Causes a Lump on Breast That Is Not Cancer?

Finding a lump in your breast can be concerning. While any new breast lump warrants medical evaluation, most are not cancerous. Many breast lumps are benign, meaning they are non-cancerous growths or changes within the breast tissue. Understanding the common causes of these benign lumps can help alleviate anxiety and guide appropriate medical assessment.

Understanding Benign Breast Lumps

Many benign conditions can result in a breast lump. These non-cancerous growths or tissue changes often have distinct characteristics. The two most frequently encountered types are fibroadenomas and breast cysts.

Fibroadenomas are solid, non-cancerous tumors of fibrous and glandular tissue. They are common in individuals between 15 and 35, but can occur at any age. These lumps typically feel firm, smooth, and rubbery, often described as a “breast mouse” due to their mobility. Fibroadenomas are usually painless, vary in size, and may grow slowly or even shrink, particularly after menopause.

Breast cysts are fluid-filled sacs that develop in breast tissue, often feeling like a grape. They are common in individuals aged 35 to 50, especially those nearing menopause. Cysts can be soft or firm, round or oval, and may increase in size and tenderness before a menstrual period, often resolving afterward. Microcysts are too small to feel, while macrocysts can be several centimeters.

Fibrocystic changes refer to general lumpiness, tenderness, and pain in the breasts, often influenced by hormonal fluctuations. This involves tiny, fluid-filled sacs and fibrous tissue, making breasts feel dense and lumpy. Fat necrosis occurs when fatty breast tissue is damaged, often due to injury, surgery, or radiation. This leads to firm, round lumps of scar tissue, usually painless but sometimes tender or causing skin changes like redness or dimpling.

Intraductal papillomas are small, wart-like growths within milk ducts, usually close to the nipple. They can present as a small lump and may cause clear or bloody nipple discharge. While benign, multiple papillomas farther from the nipple may have a slightly increased risk of breast cancer due to associated conditions. Infections like mastitis, common during breastfeeding, can also lead to hardened tissue and abscesses.

When to Consult a Doctor

Any new or concerning breast lump or change should be evaluated by a healthcare professional. While most lumps are benign, only a medical expert can accurately determine the cause.

Other signs and symptoms that warrant medical evaluation include:
Changes in the size or shape of an existing lump.
A lump that does not resolve after a menstrual cycle.
Skin changes on the breast, such as dimpling, puckering, redness, or scaling.
Nipple changes, including inversion, unusual discharge (especially if bloody), or a rash.
Persistent pain or tenderness in the breast, or swelling of all or part of the breast.

The Diagnostic Journey

When a breast lump is detected, healthcare providers follow a systematic approach. The diagnostic process begins with a clinical breast exam (CBE). A healthcare professional visually inspects and manually feels the breasts, underarms, and collarbone area for abnormalities, assessing the lump’s size, shape, texture, and mobility.

Following the physical exam, imaging tests are often used. A mammogram, an X-ray of the breast, is commonly performed, especially for individuals over 40. Ultrasound, using sound waves, distinguishes between fluid-filled cysts and solid masses, and is often preferred for younger individuals due to denser breast tissue. An MRI scan may be used for more detailed imaging.

If imaging results are inconclusive or suggest a solid mass, a breast biopsy is typically recommended. This procedure removes a sample of cells or tissue from the lump for microscopic examination. Common biopsy types include:
Fine-needle aspiration (FNA): Uses a thin needle to collect fluid or cells, particularly from cysts.
Core needle biopsy: Uses a larger, hollow needle to remove tissue cylinders, often guided by ultrasound or mammography.
Excisional (surgical) biopsy: Removes the entire lump or a larger tissue section.

Living with Benign Lumps

Once a benign diagnosis is confirmed, management depends on the lump’s type and characteristics. Many benign breast lumps, such as simple fibroadenomas and cysts, may not require active treatment. Watchful waiting and regular monitoring are common strategies, involving periodic clinical breast exams and follow-up imaging to observe changes.

For breast cysts that are large, painful, or uncomfortable, fluid drainage using fine-needle aspiration can provide relief. While cysts may refill, repeated drainage or, rarely, surgical removal may be considered if symptoms persist. Fibroadenomas, if small and asymptomatic, are often monitored. Surgical removal might be recommended if they are large, growing, or causing significant anxiety.

Infections like mastitis are treated with oral antibiotics; warm compresses help discomfort. Fat necrosis often resolves on its own, though pain can be managed with over-the-counter anti-inflammatory medications. If fat necrosis results in a persistent, symptomatic lump, surgical removal is an option. Intraductal papillomas may be surgically removed, especially if they cause nipple discharge or if atypical cells are a concern. Ongoing self-awareness and regular check-ups remain important to address any new changes.