Prader-Willi Syndrome vs. Angelman Syndrome: Key Differences

Prader-Willi Syndrome and Angelman Syndrome are two distinct neurodevelopmental conditions that arise from an issue in the same region of our genetic code. Although they share a common origin, their effects on an individual’s development, health, and behavior are different. This shared genetic basis is why they are often discussed together, yet they manifest as unique syndromes with separate lifelong paths.

The Shared Genetic Foundation

Both Prader-Willi Syndrome (PWS) and Angelman Syndrome (AS) are traced back to a specific segment of chromosome 15, the 15q11-q13 region. These conditions occur not because of a flaw in the genes themselves, but from a mechanism called genomic imprinting. This process means certain genes are expressed differently depending on which parent they are inherited from; some genes are active only on the paternal chromosome, while others are active only on the maternal one.

This parent-of-origin expression is controlled by an “imprinting center” within the 15q11-q13 region. This center applies chemical tags that silence or activate specific genes. For typical development, a person needs one active paternal and one active maternal copy of this chromosomal region. The syndromes emerge when the expression from one parent’s contribution is lost.

Prader-Willi Syndrome is caused by the loss of function of genes in the 15q11-q13 region that are normally expressed from the paternal chromosome. The most common cause is a deletion of this segment from the father’s chromosome 15. Another cause is maternal uniparental disomy (UPD), where an individual inherits two copies of chromosome 15 from their mother and none from their father.

Angelman Syndrome, conversely, results from the loss of function of a single gene within that same region, UBE3A, which is normally active only on the copy of chromosome 15 inherited from the mother. In specific areas of the brain, the paternal copy is silenced by genomic imprinting. The loss of the maternal UBE3A function is most commonly caused by a deletion on the maternal chromosome 15. Other causes include paternal uniparental disomy or a mutation within the maternal UBE3A gene itself.

Clinical Profile of Prader-Willi Syndrome

The clinical journey of an individual with Prader-Willi Syndrome unfolds in two distinct phases. The first phase begins in infancy and is marked by hypotonia, or weak muscle tone. This leads to a weak cry, lethargy, and feeding difficulties from a poor sucking reflex. Many infants require specialized feeding support to ensure they receive adequate nutrition.

A shift occurs in early childhood, between the ages of one and six, marking the second phase. This stage is defined by the onset of hyperphagia, an insatiable feeling of hunger. This drive to eat, combined with a lower metabolism, leads to chronic overeating and a high risk of obesity if not meticulously managed. This food-seeking behavior can be persistent.

Beyond hypotonia and hyperphagia, PWS is associated with a broader set of characteristics. Individuals have short stature, small hands and feet, and distinctive facial features like almond-shaped eyes. Developmental milestones are delayed, and most individuals experience some level of cognitive impairment. A specific behavioral phenotype also becomes more apparent, including temper outbursts, stubbornness, obsessive-compulsive tendencies, and compulsive skin picking. Incomplete sexual development, or hypogonadism, is another consistent feature, resulting in infertility for most.

Clinical Profile of Angelman Syndrome

The clinical presentation of Angelman Syndrome is characterized by its effects on the nervous system. Developmental delays are the first sign, becoming apparent between six and twelve months of age. These delays are severe and affect all areas of development, but they are most pronounced in speech. Individuals with AS have minimal to no use of words, though their receptive language skills are often stronger than their expressive abilities.

Motor impairments are also a central feature of the syndrome. Ataxia, a problem with balance and coordination, results in a wide-based, stiff-legged, and jerky gait. Many individuals also exhibit tremulous movements of their limbs, which contribute to challenges with mobility.

A unique behavioral phenotype is one of the most recognizable aspects of Angelman Syndrome. Individuals have a happy and excitable demeanor, with frequent smiling and laughter, and hypermotoric behaviors like hand-flapping. Seizures are a common clinical issue, with onset before the age of three. Sleep disturbances are also frequent, as is microcephaly, where the head circumference is smaller than average.

Diagnosis and Therapeutic Pathways

A suspected diagnosis of either Prader-Willi or Angelman syndrome, based on clinical features, is confirmed through targeted genetic testing. The primary diagnostic test is DNA methylation analysis. This test examines specific methylation patterns in the 15q11-q13 region, which are different depending on parental inheritance, and can identify the absence of the paternal (PWS) or maternal (AS) contribution.

Once a diagnosis is confirmed, management for Prader-Willi Syndrome focuses on managing hyperphagia and preventing obesity. This requires lifelong dietary supervision and food security, meaning access to food must be controlled. Growth hormone therapy is also a standard treatment to improve stature, muscle mass, and other metabolic issues.

Therapeutic pathways for Angelman Syndrome center on managing its neurological symptoms. Controlling seizures through anti-seizure medication is a priority. Because verbal communication is limited, speech therapy focuses on nonverbal methods, including augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) devices. Physical and occupational therapies are also utilized to address ataxia and improve motor skills.

What is an AP Site and How Does it Damage DNA?

Nonsense Mutations: Genetic Impact and Therapeutic Advances

What a Histone Image Reveals About DNA